International Examples of ‘Use it or Lose it’ Taxation on Vacant Land Parcels

World Bank

One of the tools that can be used to discourage speculation and encourage development is taxation of vacant land parcels. Many governments around the world have used this tool to motivate the private sector to develop vacant land. However, governments should not use this tool solely to address budget issues. Rather, they should use this tool to change the behavior of the private sector and block speculation.

A World Bank review of the nine cases of vacant land taxation around the world shows that various governments have different ways of defining, identifying, and prioritizing vacant land; of structuring vacant land fees; of choosing an implementation mechanism; and of deciding who benefits from the fee and how, as well as the various penalties to be imposed in the absence of required payment. There are also differences in prioritizing how to apply the taxation—whether by location, time left vacant, or degree of development. One common denominator among the case studies is the capacity of the local government in implementing the taxation, which proves to be an important factor in the success of this tool. Some observations from the review of case studies are listed below.

  • Motivations for implementing a fee. Two different traits were observed in this context. In developed countries, the main motivation seems to be addressing disinvestment and blight in cities. However, in developing countries, the focus of this tool is on fighting speculation. This is demonstrated by the examples of Brazil, China, Colombia, Korea, the Philippines, and Taiwan, China.
  • Rate setting (capacity challenges for cadaster and valuation). Having a property tax system in place is a prerequisite for implementing the vacant land tax. In the cases reviewed, the tax rate structure is based on either the assessed or market value of the property. Without having a tax collection system in place, governments cannot move to impose a vacant land fee.
  • Implementing agency, fee collection, and revenue uses. The implementing agency for imposing and collecting the tax is usually the local government. The tax revenues collected are deposited into the city’s general fund and are used for public purposes. The Philippines presents a unique case. If a city implementing a tax on idle land is located within Metropolitan Manila, then the tax revenues get split between the city and the Metropolitan Manila Authority.
  • Recourse for nonpayment of vacant land tax. The nine case studies present a similar course of action in case of delinquency of payment of the vacant land tax. This course usually involves an eventual confiscation of the vacant land by the government after applying an initial interest charge on delinquent landowners and exhausting all other channels of action to receive the vacant land tax (World Bank 2015).

Taxing vacant land parcels has its challenges and problems. Most importantly, it is a costly exercise because it requires a two-rate or split-rate property tax system to assess both improvements to the building site (if any) and the land value. As noted, assessments are expensive and many developing countries lack experienced assessors to perform a sound assessment of land value, regardless of improvements in or around it. Another issue concerns the definition of vacant land, which has to be carefully formulated to ensure an equitable taxation system while also discouraging speculation and blight. For example, comparing a 1-hectare land parcel with a single-family house to a 100-square meter land parcel with no structure on it, which one would be considered vacant and how much tax should be imposed to ensure fairness?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s