Why Greens Shouldnt Use Blocking Amendments to Stop Fracking

A thought experiment.

Imagine we discovered a magical fuel, some kind of fungus buried deep underground that didn’t just provide power but sucked up CO2 in the atmosphere.  The only problem was you had to suck it up through giant vacuum cleaners and in doing so was impractical without the consent of those who exercised subterranean minerals rights under their homes and farms, which in effect blocked it.

In those circumstances those who rightly cared about climate change would rightly lobby for changes to the law in trespass and mineral rights to mitigate climate change.  The argument being that the benefits outweighed the loss of personal property rights.

The arguments about the carbon benefits or harm of fracking are complex, and it is far from the friendliest of fuels, but lets not pretend that the blocking amendments in the commons are about protecting personal property rights, this is a pretext to block and obstruct fracking in any way possible.  If fracking is to be blocked and obstructed yes just ban it, but please lets not get hypocritical about property rights.  After all this argument could come back to haunt you if for example technological breakthroughs were made in ground source heat pumps and geothermal power.

So I find the tactics of FOE and Caroline Lucas rather annoying.  Awkward squad rather than simply and squarly opposing what is wrong and promoting what is right.

One thought on “Why Greens Shouldnt Use Blocking Amendments to Stop Fracking

  1. Other arguments aside, fracking is heavily water-intensive and leaves you with heavily contaminated water which is hard to deal with on such a small island as ours. Water-rationing will be a big issue soon as climate changes (for whatever reason) make it a scarce resource. That will push up prices in drinking water and fracking.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s